RSpec Mocks
rspec-mocks is a test-double framework for rspec with support for method stubs,
fakes, and message expectations on generated test-doubles and real objects
alike.
Install
gem install rspec # for rspec-core, rspec-expectations, rspec-mocks
gem install rspec-mocks # for rspec-mocks only
Want to run against the master
branch? You’ll need to include the dependent
RSpec repos as well. Add the following to your Gemfile
:
%w[rspec-core rspec-expectations rspec-mocks rspec-support].each do |lib| gem lib, :git => "git://github.com/rspec/#{lib}.git", :branch => 'master' end
Test Doubles
A test double is an object that stands in for another object in your system
during a code example. Use the double
method, passing in an optional identifier, to create one:
book = double("book")
Most of the time you will want some confidence that your doubles resemble an
existing object in your system. Verifying doubles are provided for this
purpose. If the existing object is available, they will prevent you from adding
stubs and expectations for methods that do not exist or that have an invalid
number of parameters.
book = instance_double("Book", :pages => 250)
Verifying doubles have some clever tricks to enable you to both test in
isolation without your dependencies loaded while still being able to validate
them against real objects. More detail is available in their
documentation.
Verifying doubles can also accept custom identifiers, just like double(), e.g.:
books = [] books << instance_double("Book", :rspec_book, :pages => 250) books << instance_double("Book", "(Untitled)", :pages => 5000) puts books.inspect # with names, it's clearer which were actually added
Method Stubs
A method stub is an implementation that returns a pre-determined value. Method
stubs can be declared on test doubles or real objects using the same syntax.
rspec-mocks supports 3 forms for declaring method stubs:
allow(book).to receive(:title) { "The RSpec Book" } allow(book).to receive(:title).and_return("The RSpec Book") allow(book).to receive_messages( :title => "The RSpec Book", :subtitle => "Behaviour-Driven Development with RSpec, Cucumber, and Friends")
You can also use this shortcut, which creates a test double and declares a
method stub in one statement:
book = double("book", :title => "The RSpec Book")
The first argument is a name, which is used for documentation and appears in
failure messages. If you don’t care about the name, you can leave it out,
making the combined instantiation/stub declaration very terse:
double(:foo => 'bar')
This is particularly nice when providing a list of test doubles to a method
that iterates through them:
order.calculate_total_price(double(:price => 1.99), double(:price => 2.99))
Consecutive return values
When a stub might be invoked more than once, you can provide additional
arguments to and_return
. The invocations cycle through the list. The last
value is returned for any subsequent invocations:
allow(die).to receive(:roll).and_return(1, 2, 3) die.roll # => 1 die.roll # => 2 die.roll # => 3 die.roll # => 3 die.roll # => 3
To return an array in a single invocation, declare an array:
allow(team).to receive(:players).and_return([double(:name => "David")])
Message Expectations
A message expectation is an expectation that the test double will receive a
message some time before the example ends. If the message is received, the
expectation is satisfied. If not, the example fails.
validator = double("validator") expect(validator).to receive(:validate) { "02134" } zipcode = Zipcode.new("02134", validator) zipcode.valid?
Test Spies
Verifies the given object received the expected message during the course of
the test. For a message to be verified, the given object must be setup to spy
on it, either by having it explicitly stubbed or by being a null object double
(e.g. double(...).as_null_object
). Convenience methods are provided to easily
create null object doubles for this purpose:
spy("invitation") # => same as `double("invitation").as_null_object` instance_spy("Invitation") # => same as `instance_double("Invitation").as_null_object` class_spy("Invitation") # => same as `class_double("Invitation").as_null_object` object_spy("Invitation") # => same as `object_double("Invitation").as_null_object`
Verifying messages received in this way implements the Test Spy pattern.
invitation = spy('invitation') user.accept_invitation(invitation) expect(invitation).to have_received(:accept) # You can also use other common message expectations. For example: expect(invitation).to have_received(:accept).with(mailer) expect(invitation).to have_received(:accept).twice expect(invitation).to_not have_received(:accept).with(mailer) # One can specify a return value on the spy the same way one would a double. invitation = spy('invitation', :accept => true) expect(invitation).to have_received(:accept).with(mailer) expect(invitation.accept).to eq(true)
Note that have_received(...).with(...)
is unable to work properly when
passed arguments are mutated after the spy records the received message.
For example, this does not work properly:
greeter = spy("greeter") message = "Hello" greeter.greet_with(message) message << ", World" expect(greeter).to have_received(:greet_with).with("Hello")
Nomenclature
Mock Objects and Test Stubs
The names Mock Object and Test Stub suggest specialized Test Doubles. i.e.
a Test Stub is a Test Double that only supports method stubs, and a Mock
Object is a Test Double that supports message expectations and method
stubs.
There is a lot of overlapping nomenclature here, and there are many
variations of these patterns (fakes, spies, etc). Keep in mind that most of
the time we’re talking about method-level concepts that are variations of
method stubs and message expectations, and we’re applying to them to one
generic kind of object: a Test Double.
Test-Specific Extension
a.k.a. Partial Double, a Test-Specific Extension is an extension of a
real object in a system that is instrumented with test-double like
behaviour in the context of a test. This technique is very common in Ruby
because we often see class objects acting as global namespaces for methods.
For example, in Rails:
person = double("person") allow(Person).to receive(:find) { person }
In this case we’re instrumenting Person to return the person object we’ve
defined whenever it receives the find
message. We can also set a message
expectation so that the example fails if find
is not called:
person = double("person") expect(Person).to receive(:find) { person }
RSpec replaces the method we’re stubbing or mocking with its own
test-double-like method. At the end of the example, RSpec verifies any message
expectations, and then restores the original methods.
Expecting Arguments
expect(double).to receive(:msg).with(*args) expect(double).to_not receive(:msg).with(*args)
You can set multiple expectations for the same message if you need to:
expect(double).to receive(:msg).with("A", 1, 3) expect(double).to receive(:msg).with("B", 2, 4)
Argument Matchers
Arguments that are passed to with
are compared with actual arguments
received using ==. In cases in which you want to specify things about the
arguments rather than the arguments themselves, you can use any of the
matchers that ship with rspec-expectations. They don’t all make syntactic
sense (they were primarily designed for use with RSpec::Expectations), but
you are free to create your own custom RSpec::Matchers.
rspec-mocks also adds some keyword Symbols that you can use to
specify certain kinds of arguments:
expect(double).to receive(:msg).with(no_args) expect(double).to receive(:msg).with(any_args) expect(double).to receive(:msg).with(1, any_args) # any args acts like an arg splat and can go anywhere expect(double).to receive(:msg).with(1, kind_of(Numeric), "b") #2nd argument can be any kind of Numeric expect(double).to receive(:msg).with(1, boolean(), "b") #2nd argument can be true or false expect(double).to receive(:msg).with(1, /abc/, "b") #2nd argument can be any String matching the submitted Regexp expect(double).to receive(:msg).with(1, anything(), "b") #2nd argument can be anything at all expect(double).to receive(:msg).with(1, duck_type(:abs, :div), "b") #2nd argument can be object that responds to #abs and #div expect(double).to receive(:msg).with(hash_including(:a => 5)) # first arg is a hash with a: 5 as one of the key-values expect(double).to receive(:msg).with(array_including(5)) # first arg is an array with 5 as one of the key-values expect(double).to receive(:msg).with(hash_excluding(:a => 5)) # first arg is a hash without a: 5 as one of the key-values
Receive Counts
expect(double).to receive(:msg).once expect(double).to receive(:msg).twice expect(double).to receive(:msg).exactly(n).times expect(double).to receive(:msg).at_least(:once) expect(double).to receive(:msg).at_least(:twice) expect(double).to receive(:msg).at_least(n).times expect(double).to receive(:msg).at_most(:once) expect(double).to receive(:msg).at_most(:twice) expect(double).to receive(:msg).at_most(n).times
Ordering
expect(double).to receive(:msg).ordered expect(double).to receive(:other_msg).ordered # This will fail if the messages are received out of order
This can include the same message with different arguments:
expect(double).to receive(:msg).with("A", 1, 3).ordered expect(double).to receive(:msg).with("B", 2, 4).ordered
Setting Responses
Whether you are setting a message expectation or a method stub, you can
tell the object precisely how to respond. The most generic way is to pass
a block to receive
:
expect(double).to receive(:msg) { value }
When the double receives the msg
message, it evaluates the block and returns
the result.
expect(double).to receive(:msg).and_return(value) expect(double).to receive(:msg).exactly(3).times.and_return(value1, value2, value3) # returns value1 the first time, value2 the second, etc expect(double).to receive(:msg).and_raise(error) # error can be an instantiated object or a class # if it is a class, it must be instantiable with no args expect(double).to receive(:msg).and_throw(:msg) expect(double).to receive(:msg).and_yield(values, to, yield) expect(double).to receive(:msg).and_yield(values, to, yield).and_yield(some, other, values, this, time) # for methods that yield to a block multiple times
Any of these responses can be applied to a stub as well
allow(double).to receive(:msg).and_return(value) allow(double).to receive(:msg).and_return(value1, value2, value3) allow(double).to receive(:msg).and_raise(error) allow(double).to receive(:msg).and_throw(:msg) allow(double).to receive(:msg).and_yield(values, to, yield) allow(double).to receive(:msg).and_yield(values, to, yield).and_yield(some, other, values, this, time)
Arbitrary Handling
Once in a while you’ll find that the available expectations don’t solve the
particular problem you are trying to solve. Imagine that you expect the message
to come with an Array argument that has a specific length, but you don’t care
what is in it. You could do this:
expect(double).to receive(:msg) do |arg| expect(arg.size).to eq 7 end
If the method being stubbed itself takes a block, and you need to yield to it
in some special way, you can use this:
expect(double).to receive(:msg) do |&arg| begin arg.call ensure # cleanup end end
Delegating to the Original Implementation
When working with a partial mock object, you may occasionally
want to set a message expecation without interfering with how
the object responds to the message. You can use and_call_original
to achieve this:
expect(Person).to receive(:find).and_call_original Person.find # => executes the original find method and returns the result
Combining Expectation Details
Combining the message name with specific arguments, receive counts and responses
you can get quite a bit of detail in your expectations:
expect(double).to receive(:<<).with("illegal value").once.and_raise(ArgumentError)
While this is a good thing when you really need it, you probably don’t really
need it! Take care to specify only the things that matter to the behavior of
your code.
Stubbing and Hiding Constants
See the mutating constants
README
for info on this feature.
Use before(:example)
, not before(:context)
Stubs in before(:context)
are not supported. The reason is that all stubs and mocks get cleared out after each example, so any stub that is set in before(:context)
would work in the first example that happens to run in that group, but not for any others.
Instead of before(:context)
, use before(:example)
.
Settings mocks or stubs on any instance of a class
rspec-mocks provides two methods, allow_any_instance_of
and
expect_any_instance_of
, that will allow you to stub or mock any instance
of a class. They are used in place of allow
or expect
:
allow_any_instance_of(Widget).to receive(:name).and_return("Wibble") expect_any_instance_of(Widget).to receive(:name).and_return("Wobble")
These methods add the appropriate stub or expectation to all instances of
Widget
.
This feature is sometimes useful when working with legacy code, though in
general we discourage its use for a number of reasons:
- The
rspec-mocks
API is designed for individual object instances, but this feature operates on entire classes of objects. As a result there are some semantically confusing edge cases. For example inexpect_any_instance_of(Widget).to receive(:name).twice
it isn’t clear whether each specific instance is expected to receivename
twice, or if two receives total are expected. (It’s the former.) - Using this feature is often a design smell. It may be that your test is trying to do too much or that the object under test is too complex.
- It is the most complicated feature of
rspec-mocks
, and has historically received the most bug reports. (None of the core team actively use it, which doesn’t help.)
Further Reading
There are many different viewpoints about the meaning of mocks and stubs. If
you are interested in learning more, here is some recommended reading:
- Mock Objects: http://www.mockobjects.com/
- Endo-Testing: http://www.ccs.neu.edu/research/demeter/related-work/extreme-programming/MockObjectsFinal.PDF
- Mock Roles, Not Objects: http://www.jmock.org/oopsla2004.pdf
- Test Double: http://www.martinfowler.com/bliki/TestDouble.html
- Test Double Patterns: http://xunitpatterns.com/Test%20Double%20Patterns.html
- Mocks aren’t stubs: http://www.martinfowler.com/articles/mocksArentStubs.html